
The trial for Sonia Exelby's alleged killer is set to begin this week, however, the man accused of her murder will not face the death penalty.
Prosecutors in the US state of Florida have been forced to take capital punishment off of the table for Dwain Hall, 54, in order to get their hands on 'crucial evidence' from UK cops.
According to The Telegraph, there was a 'total refusal' to cooperate from police on our side of the pond unless they were given assurances that Hall would not face execution.
Jury selection for the trial began on Monday (16 November), which comes more than a year after Exelby was found dead in a shallow grave in Marion County, Florida, on 17 October, 2025.
Advert
The 32-year-old classically trained musician flew to the States from her home in Portsmouth, UK, after allegedly meeting Hall on a fetish website.

It is claimed that Exelby agreed to pay him a sum of $4,000 (£3,000) to take her life, but later changed her mind. An autopsy found that she suffered four fatal stab wounds.
Exelby had been reported missing to Hampshire & Isle of Wight Constabulary on 12 October, 2025, and the force worked alongside its counterparts in the US to locate her.
Hall was arrested and charged with first-degree murder and kidnapping - and a new report claims that he implored prosecutors 'more than a hundred times' to offer him a plea deal.
According to The Telegraph, assistant state prosecutor Amy Berndt told Marion County Court last week that the she had refused to consider the alleged killer's request - but continued to be badgered by his lawyer Junior Barrett.
"I initially said no," she told the court. "He asked me so many times I did go to the family [of Exelby] and speak to them. They do not wish the state to accept a plea offer, and the state agrees.
"We will not be accepting a plea offer for Mr Hall."

Hall, a mechanic, was offered an open plea by the judge, which would mean that he could plead guilty without any promise of a reduced sentence, but he refused.
Hall could be locked up in prison for life if he is convicted, but he is not facing the prospect of being sentenced to death for the alleged killing of Exelby.
US prosecutors had to agree to rule out executing Hall after cops in the UK refused to hand over evidence.
British police are bound by law to hold back evidence in cases in the US if it could lead to the execution of a defendant - unless officials in the States agree not to pursue the death penalty.
The Florida State Attorney’s Office told The Telegraph that it was the 'first time we have ever encountered' this situation.
Why won't Hall face the death penalty?
A spokesman said: "Because of a treaty between the United States and the United Kingdom, there was a total refusal on the part of the UK to share crucial evidence unless we agreed that we would not seek the death penalty.
"This was the case, even though the victim was a citizen of the UK. Once we agreed, they made the evidence and the witnesses available and cooperated with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement (FDLE) agent."
This is down to a 2020 Supreme Court ruling in the UK, involving alleged 'Isis Beatles' Shafee El Sheikh and Alexanda Kotey. The British government were deemed to have acted unlawfully after offering evidence to prosecutors in the US without receiving assurance that the pair would not face the death penalty.
LADbible has contacted the Florida State Attorney’s Office for further comment.

Exelby's loved ones announced that they had began making their way to Florida last Thursday (12 November) after raising money for their travel via a GoFundMe page.
The fundraiser acquired £8,091 in donations from well wishers who wanted to financially aid their bid to 'be together during one of the most difficult and distressing experiences they will ever have to face'.
In an update shared to the GoFundMe last week, Exelby's sister wrote: "Stomach churning, with nerves and emotions running on overload we are all finding it hard to keep grounded this week.
"We are aware the next couple of weeks are going to be immensely difficult but we are as ready as we can be to face this next step.
"We are all slowly beginning our journeys to Florida. We are so incredibly humbled and grateful for your kindness. Each and every message, share and kind donation has given us the courage and resources to be there for Sonia."
She explained the donations would help Exelby's family 'cover the basics of flights and accommodation'.
If you're experiencing distressing thoughts and feelings, the Campaign Against Living Miserably (CALM) is there to support you. They're open from 5pm–midnight, 365 days a year. Their national number is 0800 58 58 58 and they also have a webchat service if you're not comfortable talking on the phone.



