And if you're one of the many people who has enjoyed a binge-watch, while also harbouring a bit of a crush on either of the killers - then don't worry because you're not alone.
Every time a new season of the show drops, social media is flooded with posts from people who can't help but find themselves attracted to Joe (played by Penn Badgely) and Love (played by Victoria Pedretti) .
But while you may not be the only one who fancies a fictional serial killer, You producer Sera Gamble does reckon it means you don't have great instincts when it comes to choosing a partner. Anyone else nodding along thinking, 'guilty as charged'?
Speaking to LADbible last year, Gamble said: "Part of the point of the show is that this is something many of us are scared of - that we'll pick the wrong person, who seems so great on the outside, but on the inside is a whole different story.
"I think it's very reasonable to be concerned about that because it's so hard to ever really know another person.
"And because when it comes to love, well, humans don't exactly have a reputation for great instincts. Or even good instincts."
When season two arrived last January, viewers have been taking to Twitter to voice their love for the troubled - but 'hot' - character.
One confused viewer wrote: "Watching season 2 of You again bc joe/will is so hot I'm sorry."
Professing their love, a second said: "Lol at this point wouldn't mind being with someone like Joe from You I mean he's overly dedicated, hot, notices everything... love that."
While another viewer added: "Yeah I know Will/Joe in You is borderline sociopathic but he is SO hot."
Not everyone has been taken in by Joe's charms, however - some people were adamant that he was not to be admired.
Hitting back at those who had confessed their love for the murder, one person said: "Y'all think joe/will from You is so hot and sexy until you're actually in a relationship where he's stalking you/ruining your relationships/isolating you/mentally abusing you/ruining your chances at happiness with someone other than him."
Featured Image Credit: Netflix
- Netflix has explained logic behind new series which you can watch in any order
- People are absolutely loving crazy scene in Netflix's 'perfect' new top TV series
- New Avatar: The Way of Water trailer teases epic battle between the Na'vi and humans
- Skins star April Pearson says shower scene was ‘weird’ and they shouldn’t have been made to wear such ‘tight’ clothing