
Warning: This article contains discussion which some readers may find distressing
The man accused of murdering Sonia Exelby 'manipulated and groomed her' until he 'won the job of being her executioner', a US court has heard.
Chilling details of the plot that prosecutors say 54-year-old Dwain Hall orchestrated 'for his own sadistic pleasure' have been emerging since his trial began in Ocala, Florida, this week.
He is alleged to have lured Exelby across the pond from her home in Portsmouth, UK, on the promise that he would kill her - while demanding that she pay him $4,000 (£3,000) to do so.
Advert
Exelby, a classically trained musician, was found dead in a shallow grave in Marion County, Florida, on 17 October, 2025, just days after she travelled to the US.

A jury in Ocala has heard that Exelby had wanted to die and struggled with mental illness throughout her life, which is something that Hall has been accused of 'exploiting'.
He is facing the prospect of spending life in prison if he is convicted of the first-degree murder and kidnapping of the 32-year-old Brit.
The pair met on a fetish website, where Hall went by the username 'Alpha Sadist'.
Assistant state attorney Amy Berndt told the court that the alleged killer 'manipulated' Exelby for a number of years after they began communicating.
"He targeted her because of her mental illness and he exploited her for his own sadistic pleasure," she said.
"And when he finally got her alone, thousands of miles away from home, completely incapable of making any rational decisions, he stabbed her to death and buried her body."
Men were 'competing' to kill Exelby, prosecutors say
Berndt said that Exelby had been seeking some kind of 'outlet that would make her feel alive and feel something again' amid her mental health struggles, as 'some substitute' for self-harm.
"Unfortunately, she found another outlet…about two years before her death, and ultimately that outlet would lead to her murder," the prosecutor said.
The court heard that Exelby exchanged messages with 'many different men' on the fetish website - which has since been shut down - in the hopes of finding a person 'that would kill her'.
According to Berndt, there was 'no shortage of depraved men willing to kill Sonia in the most torturous and vile ways possible' and told the court these people were 'competing for this job'.
"One man won out," jurors were told. "One man would manipulate and groom Sonia until he won the job of being her executioner. That person was the defendant Dwain Hall."

Hall is alleged to have arranged to meet Hall and follow through with the plan in March last year, but this fell through - and following this, prosecutors claim he realised he 'might as well get some money from it as well'.
"He told her that she had to bring 4,000 dollars with her when she actually came here for him to kill her," Berndt said. "Ultimately, he says he helped Sonia get what she wanted."
Exelby's body was found with four stab wounds in the left side, which a post-mortem examination found to be between four and seven inches deep and had 'all hit vital structures'.
Hall denies the charges, with his defence lawyer saying: "We believe that when you listen to all the facts and evidence in this case, you will arrive at the decision that Dwain Hall did not murder."
If you’ve been affected by any of these issues and want to speak to someone in confidence, please don’t suffer alone. Call Samaritans for free on their anonymous 24-hour phone line on 116 123 or contact Harmless by visiting their website https://harmless.org.uk.



