• iconNews
  • videos
  • entertainment
  • Home
  • News
    • UK News
    • US News
    • Australia
    • Ireland
    • World News
    • Weird News
    • Viral News
    • Sport
    • Technology
    • Science
    • True Crime
    • Travel
  • Entertainment
    • Celebrity
    • TV & Film
    • Netflix
    • Music
    • Gaming
    • TikTok
  • LAD Originals
    • Say Maaate to a Mate
    • Daily Ladness
    • Lad Files
    • UOKM8?
    • FreeToBe
    • Extinct
    • Citizen Reef
  • Advertise
  • Terms
  • Privacy & Cookies
  • LADbible Group
  • UNILAD
  • SPORTbible
  • GAMINGbible
  • Tyla
  • UNILAD Tech
  • FOODbible
  • License Our Content
  • About Us & Contact
  • Jobs
  • Latest
  • Topics A-Z
  • Authors
Facebook
Instagram
X
Threads
Snapchat
TikTok
YouTube

LAD Entertainment

YouTube

LAD Stories

Submit Your Content
Author tracked down reviewer who kept giving him one-star book reviews

Home> Community

Published 16:51 9 Apr 2023 GMT+1

Author tracked down reviewer who kept giving him one-star book reviews

Anonymous account 'Junius' was trashing Professor David Wilson's books online.

Anish Vij

Anish Vij

Professor David Wilson is a criminologist from Scotland, who decided to track down a 'troll', that had been criticising his books for months.

The 65-year-old's most recent book, Murder at Home, which has a solid 4.5/5 rating on Amazon with over 9,000 reviews, was subject to a 'cancerous' one-star review from anonymous account, 'Junius'.

Anonymous account 'Junius' was trashing Professor David Wilson's books online.
BBC

"'Junius' clearly hated my books," Wilson wrote for The Times.

Advert

"Over the years, I’d become used to his scathing one-star reviews appearing on Amazon every time I had a new one published.

"The anonymous account had become my online nemesis."

The 'troll' described the Professor's work as 'low quality' with 'poor research', and something which 'would disgrace an undergraduate dissertation'.

Wilson thought the attacks were personal.

His book was subject to a 'cancerous' one-star review from anonymous account, 'Junius'.
BBC

Advert

"Junius seemed to take things too far. His attacks were ad hominem — they seemed aimed at my credibility as much as any factual errors I might have made," he admitted.

"His one-star review of my new book immediately made an impact on the average scores, influencing the measures used by Amazon to rank new books and threatening to reduce sales.

"It was also crushing. No matter how many books you’ve written, you tend to remember the bad reviews, not the favourable ones."

The troll described the Professor's work as 'low quality'.
BBC

Instead of feeling down about the situation, the 'UK’s leading criminologist' decided to do what he was good at and 'solve the mystery'.

Advert

"I surmised that he was a historian or at least had a degree in history. Handily, he signed off his reviews with the hint of an address — 'London, Middlesex' — although there was no trace of his name," he explained.

I typed 'author', 'Dick Turpin' and 'Jacobite rebellion' into the bar of a search engine.

"Up popped several authors who had dabbled in these different areas. One caught my eye because he worked in Middlesex — the historic county that now forms part of west London: Jonathan Oates."

Oates has since apologised.
Johnathan Oates

After managing to get a hold of Oates on the phone, the fellow author immediately apologised and, according to Wilson, said: "I’m so sorry. I apologise — I know. I’m so, so sorry."

Advert

Revealing what went down, Wilson wrote: "This time, on the phone, Oates and I discussed how, if I had made factual errors, he could have emailed me at my university: I would gladly have corrected them and acknowledged his help.

"We talked about how it was clearly unethical to review the work of another author on the same topic using a pseudonym; I suggested that his attacks seemed personal rather than professional and that, as a trained historian — he has a PhD from Reading University — he should know better."

Jonathan Oates told the publication that he was too 'harsh' and apologised.

“I am Junius,” Oates said. “I suppose I am now unmasked.”

LADbible couldn't find Jonathan Oates' contact information online.

Featured Image Credit: Channel 4/Jonathan Oates

Topics: UK News

Anish Vij
Anish Vij

Anish is a Journalist at LADbible Group and is a GG2 Young Journalist of the Year 2025. He has a Master's degree in Multimedia Journalism and a Bachelor's degree in International Business Management. Apart from that, his life revolves around the ‘Four F’s’ - family, friends, football and food. Email: [email protected]

X

@Anish_Vij

Advert

Advert

Advert

  • Man who survived 9/11 shares one regret that still haunts him to this day
  • Story behind why Princess Diana always kept her head down in public
  • UFC star Paddy Pimblett turned up at gym to meet fighter who challenged him to settle the feud
  • Reason why 'radioactive man' who suffered one of the most painful deaths ever recorded was kept alive for 83 days

Choose your content:

an hour ago
17 hours ago
20 hours ago
2 days ago
  • Getty Stock ImagesGetty Stock Images
    an hour ago

    Psychologist reveals eight red flag signs that your partner is losing interest

    Psychotherapist Ioana Rotaru has revealed eight signs your partner may be losing interest

    Community
  • Getty Stock ImageGetty Stock Image
    17 hours ago

    Expert explains new ‘otrovert’ personality type and it’s very different to introverts or extroverts

    Dr Rami Kaminski coined the term after seeing qualities of it in both himself and his patients

    Community
  • YouTubeYouTube
    20 hours ago

    Navy chief who witnessed multiple UFO sightings in one evening reveals what actually happened that night

    Alexandro Wiggins has recounted his strange experience that took place while he was onboard the USS Jackson

    Community
  • Jessica Waite/InstagramJessica Waite/Instagram
    2 days ago

    Woman gets ultimate revenge on husband after finding out he cheated on her before death

    She found out he'd cheated on her a lot

    Community